TP #8: Some teachers have complained of students listening to iPods and text messaging on their cell phones during class. Students believe the offenders should be punished, but all students should not have to pay for the misbehavior of a few. As Technology Coordinator, you are asked to develop a school policy to address student use of portable electronic devices. In three-to-five paragraphs, describe the two points of view and the reasons to be more restrictive or less restrictive of portable electronic devices. Conclude with your policy recommendation to the school board and the reasons for your specific recommendation.
Technology has sometimes disadvantages besides its advantages. Hospitals, theaters, schools are troubling with the same issue, how to cut off annoying usage of cell phones and Ipods. People are always eager to abuse the general rules (sometimes they have fun). Banning the handheld devices doesn’t solve the problem, because banning is sometimes considered property theft. On the other hand, parents may not enjoy the idea of banning communication devices because of the their kid’s heath status.
Firstly, I would prefer to use cell phone jammers or cell phone alerters. Cell phone jammers would not allow the cell phones to get the signals, therefore, students could not send message to each other or chat to each other. On the other side, cell phone jamming is illegal in United States (Wollenhaupt, 2005). Cell phone jamming is considered as the same as property theft. However, There is one more alternative to the cell phone jammers called cell phone alerters. Cell phone alerters indicate if a person has a cell phone then the teachers can request the student to turn the cell phone off. I am still expecting that some of the students will abuse this request.
Secondly, Ipods are bigger problem than cell phones. I believe that all of the troubles about technology are coming out of the not knowing the ethical values. Teachers should always emphasize the ethical usages of cell phones and also Ipods over and over. Ipods are just to use in your spare time while you are traveling, waiting in the ticket line, waiting for a friend. If the student were not using the device in proper ways, I would recommend taking the device for a while.
To sum up, my school policy is:
· School will provide a cell phone alerter for each classroom. Device should be placed at the entrance of the classroom. If alerter indicates student has a cell phone, teacher will request the student to turn it off.
· If teacher realizes that student is messaging/chatting with some other friends or listening music on the ipod during class time, teacher will remind the school policy and take the student’s cell phone or ipod. During the break, teacher is going to give the device to the school principle and also parents will be notified. Teacher will tell the cell phones and ipods proper usage at school. If this happens for the second time school will take the device away until the end of the year.
· Ipods are not allowed during the class time. They can bring the device to the school (because I believe that they are listening music in the school bus or bus) but they should be turned off during class time.
· Students are allowed to use their ipods and cell phones during lunchtime, at the parking lot while they are waiting for picking up, in the hallways.
All in all, these three rules are not enough to solve the inappropriate usage of Ipods and cell phones at schools because the problem itself is not simple enough. If the school principle punishes the student by getting away the cell phone on his/her second inappropriate usage of this device, the parents can purchase a new one. More important issue than developing a policy is to teach the students about ethical values. We should tell them how to use cell phones and Ipods properly.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
I agree with you completely that these rules or restrictions may not solve the problems of inappropriate use of iPods and cell phones. The best way to solve these issues will be as you said by having a policy that will teach the students the ethics of how to use these devices.
Post a Comment